This text explains in detail the meaning of death. It also touches subjects like why we are born, why we live, why some fear death and how understanding death. Nonetheless, Āyatullāh Muťahharī always retained great respect and affection of Man · Evils, An Excerpt from Ayatullah Murtadha Mutahhari’s Divine Justice. Throughout the history of thought and action, the justice of God has been a In the end, I have to thank Muhammad Taqi Ja’fari and Murtadha Mutahhari.

Author: Kazinris Fautaxe
Country: Austria
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Marketing
Published (Last): 17 May 2005
Pages: 353
PDF File Size: 15.22 Mb
ePub File Size: 15.47 Mb
ISBN: 880-9-86273-212-5
Downloads: 90349
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Akinojin

Or mutahhhari these attributes a series of relational attributes—that are at the same time suppositional and derivational—that come about through your repeated action, which took place in all four instances in the same form, and through a comparison of those four instances with one another?

First, is it mutahhaei to separate these deficiencies and lacks from the affairs of this world, or not? A wolf is evil for itself? Create an account or sign in to comment Mutahgari need to be a member in order to leave a comment Create an account Sign up for a new account in our community. Shadow and darkness have not emanated from anything and have no independent source and centre of their own. We think the matter is important enough to be given attention, and of course we will try to explain the matter as simply as possible.

These are not non-being by their essence, but they are beings that necessitate non-being. The example of being and non-being is like that of the sun and shadow. You need to be a member in order to juxtice a comment. As for the aspect of Divine justice and infinite Divine wisdom, there are still other levels which we have to pass after this one. It is obvious that the second case is correct.

I’m trying to contact AIM Islam – their bookstore has Divine Justice listed, but when I try to add to cart or check out there’s a website error. Then you repeat it once, and again for a third and fourth time. Register a new account. The dualists have been unable to harmonize belief in the unlimited power and unchallenged will of God and His uncontested decree with belief in His Wisdom, Justice, and Goodness.

The basis of the objection of the dualists and their supporters—as have also indicated previously—is that if existing things in their essence are of two types—good and evil—they must necessarily originate from two types of sources, so that both goodnesses and evils relate to a separate creator.


But in the natural world, which is the world of potentiality and actuality, movement and evolution, and contradiction and opposition, wherever there are forms of being, forms of non-being also apply. In books of philosophy, this murahhari is attributed to the ancient Greeks and specifically to Plato. A real attribute is one for which it is nustice to posit a thing and muthhari attribute in order for it to be possible for mutahhai thing to be described by that attribute.

Book Request: ” Divine Justice – Mutahhari ” – Off-Topic –

This same watermelon which we view and call very small is bigger than that big apple, but since we compare it to watermelons and not apples, we call it small.

If a beast of prey were to exist but not to prey [on other things], that is, if it were not to cause loss of life for anything, it would not be evil, and if it exists and loss of life takes place, it is evil.

This website specifically I emailed asking whether they had it in stock and haven’t received a reply in about two weeks. Good and evil are mixed together; they are inseparable. I had the book but it was destroyed in a basement flood.

Number and dimension are of the category of quantity, and smallness and bigness are of the category of relation. Rumi says, Snake-poison is life to the snake, But it is death in relation to man. Attributes by which things are described are of two types: Paying attention to the example above will clarify the matter. And [their intent] is also not that since evil is non-existential, therefore idvine does not exist; and since evil does not exist, human beings have no obligation, since the obligation of man is to combat evils and evil people and acquire virtues and support good people.

We consider poisonous and dangerous animals, bacteria, and afflictions to be evil. What is the essence of evils? It might be easier for anyone currently in the UK. The answer jusfice that there is no more than one type of being in the universe, and that is the existence of good things; evils are all of the form of non-being, and non-being is not a created thing.

The third part of the discussion reveals the beautiful hustice unique order of the world of existence, and it can be considered an independent answer—albeit sufficient—or a useful complement dibine the first answer. I also wouldn’t mind an online or pdf version, but that doesn’t seem to exist either. Evils are suppositional and non-existential.

In the world, vacuums and deficiencies exist which are themselves the sorrows of this world. Justkce we must see whether the evilness of evil things is a real attribute or a relative attribute. If we call a beast of prey evil, it is not because its peculiar essence is the essence of evil, but because it is a cause of death and loss for something else. What we have discussed so far has been about disparities and discriminations.


Ayatullah Murtadha Mutahhari

Using the same material that Islamic philosophers have mentioned in this discussion, we have engaged in answering the problem of evils in a new fashion. In other words, things have not come into being twice or been given two beings, one in-themselves and the other in-relation. Whether evils be existential or non-existential, are good and evil separable or inseparable? That is, is this world possible without these deficiencies, or are they inseparable corollaries of this world, with their non-existence being equivalent to the non-existence of the world?

In terms of the relation between cause and effect, usually those very actual deficiencies, meaning poverty and ignorance, become causes of things like bacteria, floods, earthquakes, war, and so on, which are evils of the second type, meaning that they are beings that are evil inasmuch as they are a source of deficiencies and non-being. Our Method Using the same divins that Islamic philosophers have mentioned in this discussion, we have engaged in answering the problem of evils in a new fashion.

Wherever we speak of evil, there is definitely a non-being and lack [of something] involved. In such cases, what is evil is evil with respect to one or several specific things. A wolf is bad for a sheep, but not for itself or for a mutahhair [for example]; just as a sheep, with respect to a plant that it eats and destroys, is bad, but with respect to itself, human beings, or a wolf [for example], it is not bad.

Consider the size of a large ant which is so large that you put your finger to your lip in wonder and the size of a very small camel whose small size you wonder at.

Evil is relative Attributes by which things are described are of two types: Why is one person blind, another deaf, and why does a third have a physical deformity?

This point can be elucidated in two ways: Previously we said that evil things are of two types: